There are a number of options for recovering photos from a memory card. I’ve previously posted a list of several image recovery apps.
Whether you accidentally deleted photos on the card, formatted the card in the camera, or there’s some error with the memory card so that it has become corrupted, there’s a reasonable chance that something can be recovered.
That’s not always true, of course. The card can be so damaged that all the data has become corrupted. Or you might have kept shooting and writing over the old files.
There are free options, and there are paid options. Unfortunately, while the free options like PhotoRec can be very effective indeed, they also tend not to be very user-friendly. So if you want user-friendly, you’ll probably be looking at one of the paid options. Many of these have a trial feature that lets you do a scan to show you specifically what it’s possible to recover before you fork out for a full license to do the recovery. And some higher-end memory cards also come with an included license for photo recovery software.
Here I’m focusing on one of the popular options: Stellar Phoenix Photo Recovery.
It’s possible that it looks familiar to you even if you haven’t used it before. That’s because it’s the app that Lexar includes with some of their higher-end cards. They just put the Lexar logo on it.
Stellar Data Recovery has a range of different products for recovering data and corrupted files. The two most relevant to recovering photos from a memory card are their flagship Data Recovery and their Photo Recovery apps. Both are available for both Windows and Mac.
I’m focusing here on the Photo Recovery app. They do much the same thing. The core difference is that it limits the types of files that can be recovered to media files, which in this case refers to photo, audio, and video files. But that limitation also means that it’s cheaper than the broader version that allows recovery of a much broader range of filetypes.
There are three flavors of Photo Recovery app available for each of the Windows and Mac versions: SOHO, Platinum, and Titanium. You can find a detailed comparison table and pricing information here, but the gist is that all of them recover photo and video files. The SOHO version is the most basic. The Platinum and Titanium versions add the ability to preview and repair corrupted JPGs, and the Titanium version adds the ability to preview and repair corrupted videos.
Once you start a new recovery operation, it’ll scan for the various types of storage media you have connected, including memory cards, USB sticks, and hard drives. In this example, I’m using a CompactFlash, an SD card, and a microSD card, all of which has been formatted in-camera. When I try to look at the photos in the camera or on my computer, the cards are showing up as blank.
Down the bottom, you can choose what kind of media to scan for: photo, audio, or video. You do have fine-tuned control over the specific file extensions to look for, but for now, I’ll just do a basic search of everything. (See the Advanced Settings section below regarding narrowing the search to specific file formats.)
Once you select the source you want to scan–you can only select one at a time–you hit the Scan Now button at bottom right. You’ll then get a progress panel.”
It’ll tell you when it’s done:
Once you dismiss that little popup, you’ll get a list of nested folders in the left panel. Once you drill down to a bottom-level one you’ll see the files that were found. If you click on a file you’ll get a preview of that image at the top.
You can also change the view to thumbnails by hitting the buttons at the top:
Or a cover flow view:
If you hit the back button to go back to the source list, you can also save the scan to speed things up if you want to resume later.
Before you run a scan, you have the option of narrowing the search to specific file extensions or by a specific section of the media. All you do is hit the Advanced Settings button at the bottom right of the source selection panel.
Here’s the filetype selections:
You can also select a region of the media:
At the time of writing, this is the selection of image types that the Photo Recovery app is compatible with:
|File Extension||Image Type|
|EPS||Adobe EPS (both Mac and Windows)|
|GIF||Graphics Interchange Format|
|IFF||Interchange File Format|
|JPG, JPEG||Joint Photographic Experts Group|
|PGM||Portable Graymap Format|
|PNG||Portable Network Graphics|
|PSP||Paint Shot Pro|
|TIF, TIFF||Tagged Image Format|
And here is the list of video types:
|File Extension||Video Type|
|AVI||Audio Video Interleave|
|MP4||Moving Picture Experts Group|
|MPG, MPEG||Moving Picture Experts Group|
|MXF||Material Exchange Format|
|WMV||Windows Media Video|
One common video type that I noticed that isn’t on the list is FLV. I’m not sure why it’s not there–it might be because it’s not a format that’s typically used for capture.
It’s also compatible with quite a few audio file types, but I’m focusing here on the main types that photographers and videographers would likely be looking to recover.
- If you’ve connected your camera to your computer and it’s not showing up as an available source in the source selection panel, try taking the card out, putting it in a card reader, and then connect the card reader to the computer. That helps eliminate the camera itself or the connection between the computer and the camera as the problem.
- If you find that the photos that you’ve recovered are still corrupted, it still might be possible to repair them with the Platinum or Titanium versions.
- The scanning can only go one level deep. What I mean by that is that if the part of the memory was overwritten with another photo or other data, the bottom-most data will be lost and only the most recently written data can be recovered. Occasionally you can end up with a partial overlap. That’s pretty typically of consumer data recovery software.
You mileage might vary on what you can recover. It depends on the specific media and the circumstances of what went wrong. If you accidentally deleted photos or formatted the card, it’s often pretty straightforward. If there are physical errors on the card or it’s damaged or corrupted in a more serious way, then that probably poses a bigger problem. But even if you can’t recover everything, you might be able to recover some data from the card, so it’s well worth trying.
There are a lot of file recovery options available, several of which focus on media files. Stellar Photo Recovery is one of the more established ones, and it’s the one that Lexar has rebranded for its own uses.
I’ve found it to work well, and while it’s not the cheapest option available, its user interface is intuitive and functional. And the ability to narrow your search by either file extension or region on the disk is a handy feature that can save you time sifting through the results.
Before diving in and buying a license, I’d recommend running a scan with the trial version to see exactly what can be recovered. Then, once you’ve determined that you can, in fact, recover the files you want, buying a license will unlock the actual recovery functionality.